A Song of Ice and Fire Christian Review

And we know that in all things God works for the adept of those who love him, who accept been called co-ordinate to his purpose. —Romans 8:28

Many people can't wait for the imminent premiere of the last season of Game of Thrones. A high upkeep, loftier concept fantasy series like George R.R. Martin's magnum opus is something that gets geeks excited. As Christians, the serial certainly might invoke hesitation. I'm sure almost of us have been in Bible Studies where we wouldn't desire to acknowledge we picket Game of Thrones. Many high ranking people within the church have opined on whether or non we should be encouraging Christians to watch a series like this , and oft it'due south easier just to say no on principle. I've even met people who honey the series, only but watch information technology with their spouse in the room and then they can assist them avoid watching the nude scenes because they take previous histories of pornography addiction and feel they need to avoid those scenes.

Alas, I don't intend to wade into those waters. Christians are going to watch it anyway. The Bible calls for united states to be leaders among men and to avoid worldly things, but we're too called to go into the world. Sometimes that ways nosotros need to speak the language of culture so we can talk with people outside of the church building. That doesn't hateful we should sin in the name of talking with others, of course. It's upward to us individually every bit Christians to determine if we can tolerate such delves without compromising ourselves.

All the same, there are still arguments for why Christians should watch the show. Beyond the show'due south infamously explicit sexuality and violence, Game of Thrones and the volume series A Song of Ice and Fire present one of the most interesting longrunning stories in modern times. Between George R.R. Martin's vision of the globe and HBO's adaption, we have a show that is unflinchingly circuitous, highly-seasoned to mass audiences and morally serious. In that location's a clear view of the earth being articulated within the 8 seasons and five books, and we tin learn a lot about ourselves, our impulses, and our beliefs by sorting through it. If the about man affair in the globe is "to err," then Game of Thrones might be the nigh worldly, homo, and honest goggle box bear witness in history.

In social club to understand Game of Thrones, however, we demand to start with some other fantasy series far more implicitly Christian than Martin'due south vision of the world. The world of Westeros doesn't be in a vacuum. It was, in fact, envisioned by Martin as a directly response to one of his favorite fantasy stories of all time: The Lord of the Rings. J.R.R. Tolkien'southward vision of fantasy and magic is one of the almost beloved books of the 20th century, but it holds a special identify in the hearts of Christians. Tolkien was a devout Cosmic who famously helped C.South. Lewis convert to Christianity. While an academic who disdained mere allegory, The Lord of the Rings poured the images of a lifetime of research, experience, and heartbreak into a single story. In Tolkien's life, he experienced the horror of war firsthand as he fought in the Boxing of the Somme during some of the bloodiest days of World State of war I. The volume'southward primary influence was Tolkien's love of classical European literature, specifically Beowulf. Lord of the Rings was fundamentally an exploration of his Cosmic values through the lens of mythopoetic pagan literature and 20th-century world-weariness.

Information technology's of import to establish much of this because George R.R. Martin has a very mixed relationship with the material his series is satirizing. Part of The Lord of the Rings is fundamentally a mythic tale of civilization and tradition being handed down through the ages through stories. Martin laments the moral simplicity of Tolkien's vision of the earth. He famously snidely asked, "What was Aragorn's taxation policy?" As such, function of the idea of Game of Thrones was to rip some of information technology'south more romantic notions of legend and tradition apart. Martin disagreed with Tolkien's worldview and wanted to use his story to question the implicit moralism, religiosity, and patriarchal norms Tolkien's piece of work never commented upon. George R.R. Martin is agnostic. He views the earth in materialistic terms, numbers, and bodies. The HBO adaption of his serial reflects this with an innate focus on the human body every bit a tool to give and receive sex and violence. While there is magic in Game of Thrones, it's heavily implied at that place isn't an afterlife and death is mere pettiness.

Given Martin's radically different worldview than Tolkien's, A Song of Ice and Fire couldn't help only become subversive and confrontational. If Lord of the Rings is a fairy story about legends stretching into the modern world and guiding the states through a difficult earth in the lens of a religious story, so Game of Thrones is a story about questioning the premises of every one of Tolkien's assumptions. This, more than than the series' gratuitous nudity, speaks more to the secular roots of Game of Thrones. The serial distrusts 1000 narratives, stories, lineages, and ability. Every faction from the Starks, Lannisters, Targaryans, Baratheons, Tyrells, Wildlings, and Whitewalkers are fighting for control over their domains. Each has complicated and conflicting desires to take ability from another, frequently driven by lifetimes of tribal ideologies and fierce loyalty. The predominant religion in Westeros, The Faith of the Seven, fifty-fifty takes advantage of the power vacuum created past the conflicting wars of the serial and manages to become powerful enough to kidnap and humiliate members of the Lannister family. Whatever value the stories these factions and ideologies tell well-nigh themselves, nosotros're ultimately forced to grapple with the reality these factions are motivated past ability and the issue of their conflicts volition price an enormous amount of life while seriously changing the lives of the people of Westeros.

Role of the brilliance of Martin's vision has come from his ability to describe on existent-life historical events. Part of his strategy for edifice the earth of Westeros was to plant fantastical elements in an otherwise grounded and realistic earth. To practise that, he borrowed existent life Medieval events and transplanted them into the plot of his story. For the almost office, the events are founded in the real-life War of the Roses, a serial of English language Civil Wars that occurred during the 15th century. This gives the story a very cutting-edge power over the more fanciful story of Lord of the Rings. These events aren't the machinations of a mad writer; they largely happened to existent people. By rooting his series both in history, drawing on powerful human being emotions like lust and greed and using those tools to question the impulses that drive them, Martin's story is a comprehensive and powerful argument on the forces that drive man beings. Information technology's a story virtually incomprehension. It'due south the story of humanity'south prosperity falling by its own hubris.

Is it any wonder the series is extremely pop at a time when our own societies are buckling under the weight of political tribalism in spite of our lodge's incredible prosperity?

This is Game of Throne'due south appeal and strength. It'south a brutally honest, if secular, examination on the realities of the world that unflinchingly lets you stare into the void and find some acceptance in information technology. In some ways, it's a show that rewards cynicism nigh the globe. Information technology states life is short, vicious, and painful, only lets you relish in the pleasures of it. It'due south a nihilist tragedy. It carries a sense of New Atheism's bleak bravado baked into the show; the sense there'southward an inner strength that comes from accepting a Godless world for what it is and living life entirely in the moment. It's not dishonest that there are consequences to these realities, but it embraces this vision of the earth with confidence. There'south just one problem with this vision of the world: Information technology's incomplete.

Season 8 is merely now starting it's run, and nosotros're several weeks abroad from the serial' finale in May. As such, we don't know what the testify's creators take cooked upwards for the serial' last argument on human conflict. A large contingent of the fanbase has disliked the management of the testify post-Flavour 4 given the series has been forced to depart with Martin'southward vision for the books since they ran out of his fabric. As such, it'll be interesting to run into what kind of thematic statement the series is ultimately leading upwardly to. The answer is of import considering the final statement is ultimately the conceit of the entire premise of Game of Thrones. Without information technology, the show is a series of futile and fierce conflicts without a clear moral or sense of resolution. How do you even stop a story virtually unceasing corruption, betrayal, the lust for power, and the maintenance of legacy?

As conceived of by the YouTuber The Distributist , mayhap the most logical ending of a series like this would be for the White Walkers to siege Westeros and accept the Iron Throne. The White Walkers are a symbol of the entropy and inevitability of the unceasing conflict threatening to let loose upon the globe. Their resurgence coincides with the events that spark the struggle of the characters and the threat they pose to humanity has been left to abound unabated in the background equally conflicts persisted. Catastrophe a series about ceaseless conflict and destruction with an ultra-bleak catastrophe where everything good in the globe is smitten by inevitable death would serve Martin'due south ideas and carry them to their logical extent.

While this might be the near interesting fashion to stop the series, information technology's as well unlikely. Equally much as the series relishes killing off its ain characters, it's probable the writers of the show will ultimately prefer to let one of the established characters to seize the throne, observe some fashion to steady the conflict, and save Westeros. Equally such, it'll exist a huge deal thematically who ultimately comes to accept the Iron Throne and save Westeros. Will Daenerys Targaryen succeed in implementing her revolution, carrying along the forces of enlightenment and justice into Westeros? Will Cersei Lannister's ruthless will and lust for power hold her kingdom in the name of the in one case mighty Lannister family unit? Maybe Jon Snow will win, taking the mythopoetic part of a Christ figure past liberating Westeros to become the truthful rex. This would be thematically incongruous with the preceding material, simply would be one heck of a statement to brand. For all we know, something entirely unexpected could happen, like Varys taking the throne. This question is of import because without a satisfying answer, it'south ultimately failing to consummate the mission of presenting us a style to transcend the cycles of violence and disharmonize that birthed the very events of the serial in the offset identify. The testify has an opportunity to explore how a secular gild can save itself, and the respond it provides is important.

Listen you, none of this applies to George R.R. Martin'due south books, where it seems the story will keep down the logical track to its inevitable thematic endpoint…maybe. Martin has been famously unreliable since the release of the 5th book A Dance with Dragons in 2011. The final two books, The Winds of Wintertime and A Dream of Spring, have been perpetually in limbo as the now 70-year-old author struggles to finish the books in a timely faction. He may well pass away before finishing. Possibly this would be thematically appropriate; a long series of books about useless disharmonize and strife without an catastrophe. The meta-joke would reflect life equally he saw it then. It would truly exist well-nigh sound and fury signifying nothing.

Without a proper ending, where would that leave usa? This is an incomplete style to look at the world. It doesn't teach us to strive to brand life amend for ourselves. The moral of this story is attempt is useless in the face inevitability. Even success and fame aren't plenty of a motivation to finish two books and offer some way to make life better. I might be painting Martin'southward worldview in a far more grim light than the homo might actually believe, merely this is the unintentional statement his fine art is currently exploring. The only way to live in this world is through resignation and hedonism. It'southward spiritual death.

Ironically, the strongest reward The Lord of the Rings has over Game of Thrones is it offers u.s.a. a method of transcendence over the bleakness of life. Once more, J.R.R. Tolkien is Catholic. He was a man who actively experienced the realities of the world unfold over the course of the 20th century through useless wars and totalitarian conquest. Yet his vision of the world doesn't reflect the bleakness of Martin. In his fantasy, the world can rely on lineage, stories, and even divine intervention in the story of man's war with ultimate evil. His vision is fanciful, but it isn't dishonest. The Middle Earth Saga is a fairy story disconnected from reality, simply it's knowingly a fairy story. Information technology's cocky-aware of this reality. Tolkien understood greatly that humanity needed fairy stories to grapple with its being. When asked whether his own organized religion in Christianity was a myth, Tolkien in one case said: "Aye, they are myths that really happened."

Martin's vision through his serial is humanity is horrific and selfish, but he can't detect a way to transcend the conflicts and paradoxes his series raises about living a brutally secular life. This doesn't devalue Game of Thrones as a story. If anything, as Christians we should grapple with the success of the prove as an indication of the spiritual state of humanity. We should grapple with why we love the show or the books ourselves. If anything, our frustration with how the bear witness will terminate or how Martin may never finish the books is evidence of the truth of Tolkien'southward piece of work. Game of Thrones is fun and revels in its brutally honest depiction of homo depravity, but it only serves to turn inward on itself and collapse. In the stop, the but way to transcend the violence, selfishness, and cruelty of human being is through transcendent organized religion. We may exist blinded, dogmatic creatures serving ideas and forces we often fail to comprehend, but in service to forces more powerful than this earth, we get more the sum of our parts. Absent that, we're doomed to look for the Whitewalkers of this world to welcome united states to their ranks.

kollmansqualleave.blogspot.com

Source: https://geeksundergrace.com/tv/flawed-faith-game-of-thrones-tolkien-and-transcending-nihilism/

Share this post